Total knee replacement is usually considered when arthritis causes persistent pain, swelling, stiffness, deformity, or loss of function that no longer responds well enough to activity changes, medications, injections, bracing, therapy, or time.
The decision should match the patient's story, exam, X-rays, deformity, and goals. Some patients are better candidates for partial knee replacement, while others need total knee replacement because arthritis involves more than one compartment or ligament balance is unreliable.
Ask during consultation: Which parts of my knee are damaged, what alignment strategy do you recommend, and what recovery milestones matter most for my situation?